Exclusive Inventory

Relay partners directly with footwear brands and authorized retailers to acquire fit-based returns and surplus inventory.

Certified Pre-Owned

Our footwear experts rigorously inspect and select only the highest-quality, most desirable models for premium recommerce.

Refreshed and Refurbished

Every pair undergoes a rigorous quality check and cleaning process to ensure it looks, feels and performs like-new.

Lightning Fast Shipping

Place your order by 3 PM EST, and we’ll ship it out the same day. All orders ship within one business day.

Most Popular Footwear

View all
Save $20.01
Side view on white background of Mens New Balance XC Seven v4 running shoe in Neon Dragonfly/Poppy, Medium (Regular) width
$49.99 $70.00
Men's New Balance XC Seven v4, Neon Dragonfly/Poppy, 10.5 D MediumNew Balance
Save $30.01
Side view on white background of Womens New Balance FuelCell XC7 V5 running shoe in Black/Mint Flash/White, Medium (Regular) width
$44.99 $75.00
Women's New Balance FuelCell XC7 V5, Black/Mint Flash/White, 8.5 B MediumNew Balance
Save $30.01
Side view on white background of Mens New Balance FuelCell SD100 v5 running shoe in Dragonfly/Black, Medium (Regular) width
$44.99 $75.00
Men's New Balance FuelCell SD100 v5, Dragonfly/Black, 12.5 D MediumNew Balance
Save $30.01
Side view on white background of Womens New Balance FuelCell SD100 v5 running shoe in Dragonfly/Black, Medium (Regular) width
$44.99 $75.00
Women's New Balance FuelCell SD100 v5, Dragonfly/Black, 6 B MediumNew Balance
Save $30.01
Side view on white background of Womens New Balance FuelCell SD100 v5 running shoe in Bleached Lime Glo/Graphite/Hot Mango, Medium (Regular) width
$44.99 $75.00
Women's New Balance FuelCell SD100 v5, Bleached Lime Glo/Graphite/Hot Mango, 8.5 B MediumNew Balance
Save $40.01
Side view on white background of Womens Topo Athletic Atmos running shoe in Blue/Aqua, Medium (Regular) width
$119.99 $160.00
Women's Topo Athletic Atmos, Blue/Aqua, 10.5 B MediumTopo Athletic
Save $75.01
Side view on white background of Mens New Balance Fresh Foam X 1080 running shoe in Earth Shadow/Reflection/Urgent Red, Medium (Regular) width
$89.99 $165.00
Men's New Balance Fresh Foam X 1080v14, Earth Shadow/Reflection/Urgent Red, 11.5 D MediumNew Balance
Save $40.01
Side view on white background of Womens New Balance Fresh Foam X More running shoe in White/Sea Salt/Light Gold Metallic, Extra Wide width
$114.99 $155.00
Women's New Balance Fresh Foam X More v5, White/Sea Salt/Light Gold Metallic, 11 2E Extra WideNew Balance
Save $30.01
Side view on white background of Mens New Balance Fresh Foam 880 running shoe in NB 103 White/Blue Agate/Black, Medium (Regular) width
$109.99 $140.00
Men's New Balance Fresh Foam X 880v15, NB 103 White/Blue Agate/Black, 11 D MediumNew Balance
Save $25.01
Side view on white background of Womens Asics Novablast running shoe in Flash Red/Edo Purple, Medium (Regular) width
$124.99 $150.00
Women's Asics Novablast 5, Flash Red/Edo Purple, 10.5 B MediumAsics
Save $10.01
Side view on white background of Mens Asics Superblast running shoe in Winter Sea/White, Medium (Regular) width
$189.99 $200.00
Men's Asics Superblast 2, Winter Sea/White, 10.5 D MediumAsics
Save $20.01
Side view on white background of Mens Asics Gel-Kayano running shoe in Black/Graphite Grey, Wide width
$144.99 $165.00
Men's Asics Gel-Kayano 32, Black/Graphite Grey, 9.5 2E WideAsics
SEE ALL REVIEWS

Second Try Footwear

Relay sources fit-based returns, surplus inventory & footwear in imperfect boxes from authorized retailers and leading brands. Our footwear is practically perfect with zero-mileage normally hidden in warehouses and fulfillment centers.

Learn More

Fresh Listings

View all
Save $40.01
Side view on white background of Mens New Balance Fresh Foam 860 running shoe in Grey Matter/Black, Medium (Regular) width
$99.99 $140.00
Men's New Balance Fresh Foam X 860v14, Grey Matter/Black, 15 2E MediumNew Balance
Save $50.01
Side view on white background of Womens Brooks Adrenaline GTS running shoe in Black/Black/Ebony, Medium (Regular) width
$89.99 $140.00
Women's Brooks Adrenaline GTS 24, Black/Black/Ebony, 5.5 D MediumBrooks
Save $70.01
Side view on white background of Womens Brooks Hyperion running shoe in Illusion/Coral/Black, Medium (Regular) width
$109.99 $180.00
Women's Brooks Hyperion Max 2, Illusion/Coral/Black, 12 B MediumBrooks
Save $30.01
Side view on white background of Mens Brooks Ghost running shoe in Smoke/Primer Grey/Orange, Medium (Regular) width
$139.99 $170.00
Men's Brooks Ghost 17 GTX, Smoke/Primer Grey/Orange, 13 D MediumBrooks
Save $30.01
Side view on white background of Mens Brooks Ghost running shoe in Smoke/Primer Grey/Orange, Medium (Regular) width
$139.99 $170.00
Men's Brooks Ghost 17 GTX, Smoke/Primer Grey/Orange, 11 D MediumBrooks
Save $30.01
Side view on white background of Mens Brooks Revel running shoe in Primer/Blackened Pearl, Wide width
$69.99 $100.00
Men's Brooks Revel 8, Primer/Blackened Pearl, 11 2E WideBrooks
Save $30.01
Side view on white background of Mens New Balance Fresh Foam 880 running shoe in Slate Grey/Reflection/Urgent Red, Medium (Regular) width
$109.99 $140.00
Men's New Balance Fresh Foam X 880v15, Slate Grey/Reflection/Urgent Red, 11 D MediumNew Balance
Save $30.01
Side view on white background of Mens Brooks Revel running shoe in Primer/Blackened Pearl, Medium (Regular) width
$69.99 $100.00
Men's Brooks Revel 8, Primer/Blackened Pearl, 7.5 2E MediumBrooks
Save $30.01
Side view on white background of Womens New Balance FuelCell XC7 v5 running shoe in Ultra Pink/Black, Medium (Regular) width
$44.99 $75.00
Women's New Balance FuelCell XC7 v5, Ultra Pink/Black, 10 B MediumNew Balance
Save $25.01
Side view on white background of Womens New Balance XC Seven V2 running shoe in Tidepool/Verdite, Medium (Regular) width
$44.99 $70.00
Women's New Balance XC Seven V2, Tidepool/Verdite, 10.5 B MediumNew Balance
Save $30.01
Side view on white background of Mens New Balance FuelCell XC7 v5 running shoe in Black/Mint Flash/White, Medium (Regular) width
$44.99 $75.00
Men's New Balance FuelCell XC7 v5, Black/Mint Flash/White, 12 D MediumNew Balance
Save $30.01
Side view on white background of Womens New Balance FuelCell MD500 V9 running shoe in White/Green/Black, Medium (Regular) width
$44.99 $75.00
Women's New Balance FuelCell MD500 V9, White/Cyber Jade, 9.5 B MediumNew Balance

Certified Pre-Owned Footwear

We take the same care and attention you’d expect from CARMAX and apply it to performance footwear. Each pair is thoroughly inspected, cleaned, and ready to run, giving you all the benefits of new shoes without the price tag. Comes with a warranty too. Who says only vehicles deserve a second try?

SHOP PRE-OWNED

Footwear Under $100

View all
Save $20.01
Side view on white background of Mens New Balance XC Seven v4 running shoe in Neon Dragonfly/Poppy, Medium (Regular) width
$49.99 $70.00
Men's New Balance XC Seven v4, Neon Dragonfly/Poppy, 10.5 D MediumNew Balance
Save $30.01
Side view on white background of Womens New Balance FuelCell XC7 V5 running shoe in Black/Mint Flash/White, Medium (Regular) width
$44.99 $75.00
Women's New Balance FuelCell XC7 V5, Black/Mint Flash/White, 8.5 B MediumNew Balance
Save $30.01
Side view on white background of Mens New Balance FuelCell SD100 v5 running shoe in Dragonfly/Black, Medium (Regular) width
$44.99 $75.00
Men's New Balance FuelCell SD100 v5, Dragonfly/Black, 12.5 D MediumNew Balance
Save $30.01
Side view on white background of Womens New Balance FuelCell SD100 v5 running shoe in Dragonfly/Black, Medium (Regular) width
$44.99 $75.00
Women's New Balance FuelCell SD100 v5, Dragonfly/Black, 6 B MediumNew Balance
Save $30.01
Side view on white background of Womens New Balance FuelCell SD100 v5 running shoe in Bleached Lime Glo/Graphite/Hot Mango, Medium (Regular) width
$44.99 $75.00
Women's New Balance FuelCell SD100 v5, Bleached Lime Glo/Graphite/Hot Mango, 8.5 B MediumNew Balance
Save $75.01
Side view on white background of Mens New Balance Fresh Foam X 1080 running shoe in Earth Shadow/Reflection/Urgent Red, Medium (Regular) width
$89.99 $165.00
Men's New Balance Fresh Foam X 1080v14, Earth Shadow/Reflection/Urgent Red, 11.5 D MediumNew Balance
Save $75.01
Side view on white background of Mens New Balance Fresh Foam X 1080 running shoe in Urgent Red/Reflection/Black, Medium (Regular) width
$89.99 $165.00
Men's New Balance Fresh Foam X 1080v14, Urgent Red/Reflection/Black, 8.5 D MediumNew Balance
Save $75.01
Side view on white background of Mens New Balance Fresh Foam X 1080 running shoe in Pale Moss/New Spruce, Medium (Regular) width
$89.99 $165.00
Men's New Balance Fresh Foam X 1080v14, Pale Moss/New Spruce, 9.5 D MediumNew Balance
Save $75.01
Side view on white background of Womens New Balance Fresh Foam X 1080 running shoe in Rose Sugar/Twilight Haze/Sea Salt/Arid Stone, Medium (Regular) width
$89.99 $165.00
Women's New Balance Fresh Foam X 1080v14, Rose Sugar/Twilight Haze/Sea Salt/Arid Stone, 6 B MediumNew Balance
Save $75.01
Side view on white background of Womens New Balance Fresh Foam X 1080 running shoe in Black/Phantom, Medium (Regular) width
$89.99 $165.00
Women's New Balance Fresh Foam X 1080v14, Black/Phantom, 9.5 B MediumNew Balance
Save $60.01
Side view on white background of Mens Altra Experience running shoe in Black/White, Medium (Regular) width
$79.99 $140.00
Men's Altra Experience Flow, Black/White, 8.5 D MediumAltra

Shop By Brand